A historic church tower in the Yorkshire Dales has become the centre of a heated dispute after being rendered bright white.
Residents of Askrigg in Wensleydale have branded Grade I-listed St Oswald's Church an "eyesore" after Reverend Dave Clark had its 15th-century tower covered in limewash render.
The transformation was revealed this week when scaffolding and plastic sheeting were removed.
Photographs show the tower now stands in stark contrast to the remaining grey stonework of the church.
The village, which served as the setting for Darrowby in the BBC's All Creatures Great and Small, has been left divided by the controversial renovation.
Emma Brooke, a 63-year-old local businesswoman, launched a "stop the rendering" petition, which garnered 438 signatures in a village with just 500 residents.
She called the situation a "disgrace", adding: "From the hills that surround the village it can be seen for miles and looks so out of place, particularly when the rest of the church has been left in its original state."
Paul Halton, 73, said the vicar had "disfigured the church" and "changed the face of the village".
Rachel Tysoe, who lives two miles away in Thornton Rust, said she can still see the tower.
MORE LIKE THIS:
"You could never see the house before but now there's no missing it," she added.
Reverend Clark defended the renovation, insisting the render "is a honey hue made from local stone" rather than white.
He told The Telegraph that limewashing is reversible, adding: "So if 50 years down the line there's a new technology that can fulfil the same function, it can be changed."
The vicar explained the rendering was necessary to prevent water from leaking through the brickwork.
"With my hand on my heart, I can say it is not white - and when you look at it properly, you can see that," he stated.
LATEST FROM YORKSHIRE:
He also acknowledged the controversy, saying: "In a few months, I'm hoping people will get used to the new rendering and that it will weather and fade down."
Reverend Clark noted the church had been standing for 600 years before Victorians removed it in the 1850s.
"There would be greater distress if the tower had fallen down or if the bells came loose and fell through the floor," he warned.
Despite the backlash, some residents have expressed support for the limewash on social media.
One supporter wrote: "I rather like it. A bit of a beacon - can see it from miles away around the Dale. It's almost ethereal which is apt for the church tower."
Another commented: "It needs to be done to help preserve it, as terrible as it looks it's better it being that colour than it becoming unusable and possibly degrading over time."
Find Out More...
Residents of Askrigg in Wensleydale have branded Grade I-listed St Oswald's Church an "eyesore" after Reverend Dave Clark had its 15th-century tower covered in limewash render.
The transformation was revealed this week when scaffolding and plastic sheeting were removed.
Photographs show the tower now stands in stark contrast to the remaining grey stonework of the church.
The village, which served as the setting for Darrowby in the BBC's All Creatures Great and Small, has been left divided by the controversial renovation.
Emma Brooke, a 63-year-old local businesswoman, launched a "stop the rendering" petition, which garnered 438 signatures in a village with just 500 residents.
She called the situation a "disgrace", adding: "From the hills that surround the village it can be seen for miles and looks so out of place, particularly when the rest of the church has been left in its original state."
Paul Halton, 73, said the vicar had "disfigured the church" and "changed the face of the village".
Rachel Tysoe, who lives two miles away in Thornton Rust, said she can still see the tower.
MORE LIKE THIS:
- More than 3,500 churches have shut across Britain in last decade with some even converted into mosques
- Church of England puts swift end to conversion of Grade II-listed building into mosque
- Church of England set for woke rebrand as it suggests dropping word ‘church’ to be more ‘modern’
"You could never see the house before but now there's no missing it," she added.
Reverend Clark defended the renovation, insisting the render "is a honey hue made from local stone" rather than white.
He told The Telegraph that limewashing is reversible, adding: "So if 50 years down the line there's a new technology that can fulfil the same function, it can be changed."
The vicar explained the rendering was necessary to prevent water from leaking through the brickwork.
"With my hand on my heart, I can say it is not white - and when you look at it properly, you can see that," he stated.
LATEST FROM YORKSHIRE:
- Sheffield businesses admit they ‘hoped for more’ from Rachel Reeves’s Spring Statement
- British man fined for housing pet ALLIGATOR in his back garden
- South Yorkshire miners 40 years on after year-long strike: ‘No victory'
He also acknowledged the controversy, saying: "In a few months, I'm hoping people will get used to the new rendering and that it will weather and fade down."
Reverend Clark noted the church had been standing for 600 years before Victorians removed it in the 1850s.
"There would be greater distress if the tower had fallen down or if the bells came loose and fell through the floor," he warned.
Despite the backlash, some residents have expressed support for the limewash on social media.
One supporter wrote: "I rather like it. A bit of a beacon - can see it from miles away around the Dale. It's almost ethereal which is apt for the church tower."
Another commented: "It needs to be done to help preserve it, as terrible as it looks it's better it being that colour than it becoming unusable and possibly degrading over time."
Find Out More...