A former police officer pleaded guilty to assault after shoving his neighbour during a heated dispute over a car trailer.
Paul Hegarty, 63, who served with British Transport Police for 19 years, pushed his neighbour Robert Dougall three times during an argument outside their homes in Ferndown, Dorset.
The confrontation was the culmination of ongoing tensions between the neighbours over Dougall's use of a car trailer, which he used to transport broken-down vehicles to his garage.
The Hegartys had accused Dougall of blocking their driveway with the trailer, despite it being legally parked.
The dispute escalated when anonymous notes were left on Dougall's windscreen, claiming he wasn't allowed to park there as it could cause an accident. A noise complaint was subsequently filed with the local council, reports The Telegraph.
When Dougall applied for planning permission to demolish his garage and build a larger one for his hobby, several neighbours objected.
Hegarty described the noise from his garage as "horrendous" in her complaint.
"The noise that comes from the existing garage from pneumatic tools and compressors from early to 10pm all days of the week is horrendous. This is not a hobby or obsession but a full-time mechanics' workshop," she stated.
LATEST NEWS FROM COURT
After parking, Hegarty tutted and shook his head at Dougall, who asked what the problem was. An argument ensued, during which Dougall swore. Hegarty told him, "Don't start swearing in front of my wife," before pushing him in the chest.
When Dougall protested, Hegarty pushed him again. After Dougall threatened to call police, Hegarty shoved him a third time. CCTV footage later disproved Hegarty's claim that Dougall had threatened his wife during the incident.
At Poole Magistrates' Court, Hegarty pleaded guilty to assault by beating.
His defence lawyer, Selina Goddard, said he had no previous convictions and was "under pressure" while undergoing tests for cancer, telling the court: "It's particularly sad he finds himself in this situation at this time of life."
Judge Orla Austin gave Hegarty a 12-month conditional discharge, saying it was "extremely unfortunate" he was in court for the first time at 63.
Speaking after the case, Dougall said the neighbours had been upset about the trailer from the beginning.
"From the day we moved in, they were angry about that trailer. Every time I used it, they got upset," he said.
He denied allegations about excessive noise, saying claims he had been "revving engines all day long" were untrue. Dougall described his surprise at Hegarty's anger during the confrontation.
He told The Telegraph: "It was a hard shove, I had to take several steps back. He's taller and bigger than me and I had something in my hands, so I didn't even raise my arms."
Find Out More...
Paul Hegarty, 63, who served with British Transport Police for 19 years, pushed his neighbour Robert Dougall three times during an argument outside their homes in Ferndown, Dorset.
The confrontation was the culmination of ongoing tensions between the neighbours over Dougall's use of a car trailer, which he used to transport broken-down vehicles to his garage.
The Hegartys had accused Dougall of blocking their driveway with the trailer, despite it being legally parked.
The dispute escalated when anonymous notes were left on Dougall's windscreen, claiming he wasn't allowed to park there as it could cause an accident. A noise complaint was subsequently filed with the local council, reports The Telegraph.
When Dougall applied for planning permission to demolish his garage and build a larger one for his hobby, several neighbours objected.
Hegarty described the noise from his garage as "horrendous" in her complaint.
"The noise that comes from the existing garage from pneumatic tools and compressors from early to 10pm all days of the week is horrendous. This is not a hobby or obsession but a full-time mechanics' workshop," she stated.
LATEST NEWS FROM COURT
- 'Two-tier' justice plans drawn up by MoJ as judges told to 'prioritise' ethnic minorities for bail
- NHS nurses take hospital trust to court after allowing trans colleague into female changing rooms: 'It's unlawful!'
- Tommy Robinson moved to 'closed wing' in prison after 'mark on his head and threats he would be killed by a lifer'
After parking, Hegarty tutted and shook his head at Dougall, who asked what the problem was. An argument ensued, during which Dougall swore. Hegarty told him, "Don't start swearing in front of my wife," before pushing him in the chest.
When Dougall protested, Hegarty pushed him again. After Dougall threatened to call police, Hegarty shoved him a third time. CCTV footage later disproved Hegarty's claim that Dougall had threatened his wife during the incident.
At Poole Magistrates' Court, Hegarty pleaded guilty to assault by beating.
His defence lawyer, Selina Goddard, said he had no previous convictions and was "under pressure" while undergoing tests for cancer, telling the court: "It's particularly sad he finds himself in this situation at this time of life."
Judge Orla Austin gave Hegarty a 12-month conditional discharge, saying it was "extremely unfortunate" he was in court for the first time at 63.
Speaking after the case, Dougall said the neighbours had been upset about the trailer from the beginning.
"From the day we moved in, they were angry about that trailer. Every time I used it, they got upset," he said.
He denied allegations about excessive noise, saying claims he had been "revving engines all day long" were untrue. Dougall described his surprise at Hegarty's anger during the confrontation.
He told The Telegraph: "It was a hard shove, I had to take several steps back. He's taller and bigger than me and I had something in my hands, so I didn't even raise my arms."
Find Out More...